The following is a list of the vicars who have served in the Parish of Hartford since 1864. These are therefore all the incumbents since the present church was built.
| Rev. Edmund Eddowes | 1864-1908 |
| Rev. Norman John Neil Gourlie | 1908-1914 |
| Rev. Harry Herbert Pitts | 1914-1925 |
| Rev. Ernest Scales Oliver | 1925-1939 |
| Rev. Frederick Philip Cheetham | 1939-1958 |
| Rev. Maurice James Fraser Wilson | 1959-1969 |
| Rev. Jack Wardle | 1969-1978 |
| Rev. Maurice P. Marshall | 1979-1989 |
| Rev. Dr. Paul Gardner | 1990-2003 |
| Rev. Mike Smith | 2004 |
